Eve library

phase-72-audit.md

Tracker

Revision 1

On this page

Historical task source. The Eve task board holds current task state.

Phase 72 Completion Audit#

Date: 2026-06-19

Scope: TODOS/phase-72.md and the repository evidence that could justify its 706 checked boxes.

Result#

The Phase 72 checkmarks were not trustworthy as completion markers. I reset all 706 task boxes in TODOS/phase-72.md to unchecked.

This is intentionally conservative. A box may be re-checked only when the specific task has concrete implementation and verification evidence matching the task wording. Planning documents, JSON manifests, checker scripts, view-model surfaces, adapter interfaces, and partial prototypes are useful evidence, but they are not sufficient for a completed checkbox when the task claims production integration, vendor SDK support, live operations, deployed infrastructure, or validated model/GPU behavior.

Audit Rule#

  • Keep checked: source implementation plus automated verification directly covers the task wording.
  • Leave unchecked: docs-only, manifest-only, checker-only, adapter-only, prototype-only, or implementation whose scope is materially narrower than the task wording.
  • Leave unchecked: claims requiring external vendor SDKs, live services, production fleets, signed binaries, measured datasets, or platform/devkit validation when those artifacts are not present in the repo.

Key Findings#

Area Audit finding
Release inventory docs/releases/v1/domains/neith/README.md labels every Phase 72 domain as planned-or-partially-implemented, which contradicts a file where every task is checked complete.
72.1 Neural rendering The repo has a non-neural maya-renderer radiance cache and an @aphrodite/neural-rendering style-transfer/scene-enhancement package. I did not find matching DirectX Cooperative Vectors, Vulkan cooperative matrix, Metal ML, NRC training/inference, or ONNX denoiser integration evidence for the checked task wording.
72.2 Server and fleet V2 contains contracts, manifests, docs, and checker scripts for server/fleet behavior. That is not the same as a deployed fleet manager, autoscaling service, multi-region infrastructure, canary service, or disaster-recovery system.
72.3 Build and cooking V2 contains CI/config/planner coverage for build acceleration and cooking. Several claims describe a real distributed build farm, cook daemon, dashboards, and multi-platform build outputs that are not proven by the checked boxes alone.
72.4 DRM V2 DRM docs/manifests and DRM media-library code exist, but the task wording claims executable packing, runtime unpacking, anti-debugging, binary signing, Denuvo/custom provider integration, A/B testing, and protected-build verification. These are not proven as completed production integrations.
72.5 Telemetry and analytics Runtime telemetry code and V2 telemetry contracts exist. The checked list also claims ingestion services, Kafka/Kinesis-style pipelines, dashboards, model-based churn prediction, BI exports, and live alerting. Those operational claims remain unproven.
72.6 Profiling Rust profiler and renderer marker abstractions exist, along with V2 profiling manifests. Several checked items are adapter/command-stream abstractions or tool workflow plans rather than native RenderDoc/PIX/Xcode/Nsight/Superluminal integrations proven end to end.
72.7-72.18 RPG/game systems There is substantial @aphrodite/game-rpg, runtime, accessibility, camera, and live-ops source/test coverage. The checklist still overstates completion in places that require in-engine UI, deployed services, cinematic integration, NPC scheduling, economy operations, or end-to-end gameplay validation.
72.19 Playtesting bots @aphrodite/game-testing has deterministic bot and report surfaces. Long soak runs, large bot armies, CI/nightly execution, and trained RL behavior are not proven as completed operational gates.
72.20 Asset version control @aphrodite/game-assets and V2 source-control policy coverage exist. Studio-grade LFS storage backends, locking workflows, backup/disaster recovery, and binary diff tooling are not fully proven by the checked boxes.
72.21 Platform SDK @aphrodite/game-runtime has platform abstraction tests and docs, but real Steamworks, EOS, GOG Galaxy, PlayStation, Xbox, and compliance/devkit integrations are not established as completed.
72.22 and 72.28 Audio @aphrodite/game-audio has adaptive music and Wwise/FMOD-shaped middleware abstractions. The source comments explicitly describe runtime integrations as future bindings, so checked boxes claiming actual Wwise/FMOD SDK initialization and soundbank runtime integration overclaim the evidence.
72.24-72.30 Gameplay/rendering systems Multiple packages contain real implementation and tests for character/gameplay, HUD/UI-adjacent data, replay, input, and shaders. The checked wording still includes end-to-end UI, platform-specific haptics/icons, cloud replay sharing, native shader cross-compilation outputs, and build-farm distribution that need narrower per-task proof.
72.31-72.34 Neith crates The new Rust crates have meaningful prototypes and tests. Some task wording still exceeds the implementation, such as real GPU topology solves, real FabricGen/WeavingLLM integration, trained AI material predictors, and measured BRDF validation datasets.

Recheck Requirements#

Before any item is marked checked again, add or cite the smallest adequate evidence set:

  • source file or manifest implementing the exact behavior;
  • automated test, checker, or validation command that exercises it;
  • external-integration proof when the task depends on vendor SDKs, cloud services, platform/devkit behavior, signed artifacts, or production telemetry;
  • documentation only for tasks whose deliverable is explicitly documentation.

Notes For Future Agents#

Do not use TODOS/phase-72.md as evidence that Phase 72 is complete. Use it as the work queue. The release inventory currently gives the more accurate status: Phase 72 domains are planned or partially implemented until each task is re-audited against concrete evidence.