## Phase 72 Completion Audit

Date: 2026-06-19

Scope: `TODOS/phase-72.md` and the repository evidence that could justify its
706 checked boxes.

### Result

The Phase 72 checkmarks were not trustworthy as completion markers. I reset all
706 task boxes in `TODOS/phase-72.md` to unchecked.

This is intentionally conservative. A box may be re-checked only when the
specific task has concrete implementation and verification evidence matching the
task wording. Planning documents, JSON manifests, checker scripts, view-model
surfaces, adapter interfaces, and partial prototypes are useful evidence, but
they are not sufficient for a completed checkbox when the task claims production
integration, vendor SDK support, live operations, deployed infrastructure, or
validated model/GPU behavior.

### Audit Rule

- Keep checked: source implementation plus automated verification directly
  covers the task wording.
- Leave unchecked: docs-only, manifest-only, checker-only, adapter-only,
  prototype-only, or implementation whose scope is materially narrower than the
  task wording.
- Leave unchecked: claims requiring external vendor SDKs, live services,
  production fleets, signed binaries, measured datasets, or platform/devkit
  validation when those artifacts are not present in the repo.

### Key Findings

| Area                                   | Audit finding                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                                      |
| -------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |
| Release inventory                      | `docs/releases/v1/domains/neith/README.md` labels every Phase 72 domain as `planned-or-partially-implemented`, which contradicts a file where every task is checked complete.                                                                                                                                                                      |
| 72.1 Neural rendering                  | The repo has a non-neural `maya-renderer` radiance cache and an `@aphrodite/neural-rendering` style-transfer/scene-enhancement package. I did not find matching DirectX Cooperative Vectors, Vulkan cooperative matrix, Metal ML, NRC training/inference, or ONNX denoiser integration evidence for the checked task wording.                      |
| 72.2 Server and fleet                  | V2 contains contracts, manifests, docs, and checker scripts for server/fleet behavior. That is not the same as a deployed fleet manager, autoscaling service, multi-region infrastructure, canary service, or disaster-recovery system.                                                                                                            |
| 72.3 Build and cooking                 | V2 contains CI/config/planner coverage for build acceleration and cooking. Several claims describe a real distributed build farm, cook daemon, dashboards, and multi-platform build outputs that are not proven by the checked boxes alone.                                                                                                        |
| 72.4 DRM                               | V2 DRM docs/manifests and DRM media-library code exist, but the task wording claims executable packing, runtime unpacking, anti-debugging, binary signing, Denuvo/custom provider integration, A/B testing, and protected-build verification. These are not proven as completed production integrations.                                           |
| 72.5 Telemetry and analytics           | Runtime telemetry code and V2 telemetry contracts exist. The checked list also claims ingestion services, Kafka/Kinesis-style pipelines, dashboards, model-based churn prediction, BI exports, and live alerting. Those operational claims remain unproven.                                                                                        |
| 72.6 Profiling                         | Rust profiler and renderer marker abstractions exist, along with V2 profiling manifests. Several checked items are adapter/command-stream abstractions or tool workflow plans rather than native RenderDoc/PIX/Xcode/Nsight/Superluminal integrations proven end to end.                                                                           |
| 72.7-72.18 RPG/game systems            | There is substantial `@aphrodite/game-rpg`, runtime, accessibility, camera, and live-ops source/test coverage. The checklist still overstates completion in places that require in-engine UI, deployed services, cinematic integration, NPC scheduling, economy operations, or end-to-end gameplay validation.                                     |
| 72.19 Playtesting bots                 | `@aphrodite/game-testing` has deterministic bot and report surfaces. Long soak runs, large bot armies, CI/nightly execution, and trained RL behavior are not proven as completed operational gates.                                                                                                                                                |
| 72.20 Asset version control            | `@aphrodite/game-assets` and V2 source-control policy coverage exist. Studio-grade LFS storage backends, locking workflows, backup/disaster recovery, and binary diff tooling are not fully proven by the checked boxes.                                                                                                                           |
| 72.21 Platform SDK                     | `@aphrodite/game-runtime` has platform abstraction tests and docs, but real Steamworks, EOS, GOG Galaxy, PlayStation, Xbox, and compliance/devkit integrations are not established as completed.                                                                                                                                                   |
| 72.22 and 72.28 Audio                  | `@aphrodite/game-audio` has adaptive music and Wwise/FMOD-shaped middleware abstractions. The source comments explicitly describe runtime integrations as future bindings, so checked boxes claiming actual Wwise/FMOD SDK initialization and soundbank runtime integration overclaim the evidence.                                                |
| 72.24-72.30 Gameplay/rendering systems | Multiple packages contain real implementation and tests for character/gameplay, HUD/UI-adjacent data, replay, input, and shaders. The checked wording still includes end-to-end UI, platform-specific haptics/icons, cloud replay sharing, native shader cross-compilation outputs, and build-farm distribution that need narrower per-task proof. |
| 72.31-72.34 Neith crates               | The new Rust crates have meaningful prototypes and tests. Some task wording still exceeds the implementation, such as real GPU topology solves, real FabricGen/WeavingLLM integration, trained AI material predictors, and measured BRDF validation datasets.                                                                                      |

### Recheck Requirements

Before any item is marked checked again, add or cite the smallest adequate
evidence set:

- source file or manifest implementing the exact behavior;
- automated test, checker, or validation command that exercises it;
- external-integration proof when the task depends on vendor SDKs, cloud
  services, platform/devkit behavior, signed artifacts, or production telemetry;
- documentation only for tasks whose deliverable is explicitly documentation.

### Notes For Future Agents

Do not use `TODOS/phase-72.md` as evidence that Phase 72 is complete. Use it as
the work queue. The release inventory currently gives the more accurate status:
Phase 72 domains are planned or partially implemented until each task is
re-audited against concrete evidence.
