This receipt closes the current-artifact visual-review checkpoint for
v2-product-promise and v2-product-surfaces. Both delivered PDFs changed
after the older 21-page ledger, so that historical review no longer bound the
current files. The new visual ledger binds and records a
fresh inspection of every current page.
Reviewed visuals#
- All nine player-promise PDF pages and all twelve game/web/companion PDF pages were rastered at 1440×810 and inspected individually. Titles, subtitles, tables, graphs, flows, takeaways and footers remain visible and unclipped.
- Four embedded 390×844 states cover the two split ruleset tables, the ownership reading alternative and the companion contract. Two full-height 390px standalone captures establish the complete ownership and companion reading paths.
- A 1440×900 embedded capture records the ownership graph in the normal center workspace. All six nodes, labels, connectors and the authority caveat remain visible.
- The repaired Auth contract and Mobile app labels remain intact at 16px in the complete phone table. A controlled restoration of Authentication contract at 125% type and 320px is rejected when it splits the word.
The two contact sheets are navigation aids. The acceptance observations and hashes belong to the 28 individually reviewed primary images, not to the reduced overview alone.
Findings kept open#
Six independent column comparisons still show 01–04, which can imply a
sequence that their content does not define:
- player-promise pages 6 and 7: audience requirements and cross-platform requirements;
- surfaces pages 2, 4, 7 and 10: game-front-end responsibilities, accessibility boundaries, result/operations records and companion support roles.
Ordinals remain appropriate on player-promise pages 5 and 9 and surfaces page 12 because those slides describe actual progressions.
The standard embedded ownership graph renders its title labels at 16px high and detail labels at 14px high. The content remains readable in the retained capture and becomes 23px/18px in the mobile reading alternative, but 14px is too small to promote as accepted presentation typography. Recomposition or larger type, compact-height review and willing-reader feedback remain separate TODOs.
Automated verification#
v2-visual-review.mjs reproduces seven browser captures and checks content
bounds, 16px mobile content floors, whole-word table labels, the complete
ownership reading alternative, accessibility, page width and artifact
immutability. It also proves the long-label failure control is effective.
The complete standalone guide suites pass all 21 slides at desktop, compact and mobile sizes, their ten table-readability groups, both PDF sequences and actual narration controls. The focused center run selects the two V2 guides plus the 25 guides required by the older canonical center baseline: 27 selected guides, 33 unchanged guides, 462 embedded slide captures and 27 PDF sequences pass in the current 60-guide library.
Builder and narration freshness remain separate integrity checks. This visual review does not claim normal-speed listening, projection testing, reader comprehension or final acceptance of the two open composition findings.
Reproduce#
Run browser gates serially with the prepared presentation dependencies:
OSHUN_V2_VISUAL_QA_DIR=/tmp/v2-visual CHROME_CHANNEL=chromium \
python3 tools/presentations/run-supervised.py \
node tools/presentations/tests/v2-visual-review.mjs
OSHUN_DECK_QA_DIR=/tmp/v2-promise CHROME_CHANNEL=chromium \
python3 tools/presentations/run-supervised.py \
node tools/presentations/tests/eve-oshun-deck.mjs --guide v2-product-promise
OSHUN_DECK_QA_DIR=/tmp/v2-surfaces CHROME_CHANNEL=chromium \
python3 tools/presentations/run-supervised.py \
node tools/presentations/tests/eve-oshun-deck.mjs --guide v2-product-surfaces
Raster the two delivered PDFs with pdftoppm, using -png,
-scale-to-x 1440, and -scale-to-y -1. verify-receipt.py checks the
current artifact hashes, retained evidence, report structure, visual ledger and
live focused browser script.
python3 docs/presentations/presentation-center/verification/v2-visual-review-2026-09-08/verify-receipt.py