# Member narration and source review — 2026-09-06

The [full checklist](../../TODOS.md) remains active. This is a partial narration
and teaching checkpoint, not complete whole-monorepo coverage, live Eve
integration, Domains acceptance or the final visual/listening review. Source
claims retain revision `1ceae52c7896a59ac74a4429d410f3218f0b91c6`.

## Current audio

Two sequential one-thread CPU batches rendered nine pending recordings and
replaced two corrected explanations. Both processes exited normally with code 0.
The stock Kokoro voice, model revision, pronunciation and timing policy are
unchanged: [batch 1](narration-1.txt), [batch 2](narration-2.txt).

The [current-audio audit](current-audio-check.json) verifies **125 tracks,
10,180.758 seconds and 1,591 sentence segments** against actual speech
fingerprints, file hashes/bytes, decoded duration and encoded pauses. **256
tracks remain pending: 236 stale and 20 missing.** V1 web/PWA, Tara and Arete
now have complete audio. These mechanical checks do not establish a normal-speed
listening review.

## Standalone playback verification

All three non-draft standalone suites exited normally and passed **30 slide
instances**:

| Guide      | Slides | Report                            |
| ---------- | -----: | --------------------------------- |
| V1 web/PWA |     11 | [Result](v1-web-pwa-browser.json) |
| Tara       |     10 | [Result](tara-browser.json)       |
| Arete      |      9 | [Result](arete-browser.json)      |

Adjacent `-browser.txt` logs retain the runs. Coverage includes
desktop/compact/mobile layout, axe accessibility, source/script alignment,
navigation, dialogs, print sequence, actual decode/play/pause/resume/seek/speed
and end transitions, HTTP failures, missing/corrupt audio, retries, playback
races and portable local-file behavior. No narrator was running during these
checks. The browser reports bind the exact delivered HTML, not a subsequently
rebuilt variant.

The [complete center run](center-ready-audio.json) also exited normally with
code 0. It covers **38 guides, 407 embedded slide instances and 38 PDF
exports**, with 814 desktop/mobile initial-viewport captures. All capture bytes
were revalidated against their report hashes. The run uses
`--draft --ready-audio`: 26 desktop/mobile playback boundaries cover the 13
ready guides; the remaining 25 guides are explicitly excluded from audio
acceptance. Navigation, hierarchy, listening-time semantics, search, browser
history, drawer/focus handling and the local interaction budget pass. This is
not full-library audio acceptance.

## Targeted visual review

The [visual ledger](visual-review.json) binds **13 inspected images across two
unique slides and two guide contexts** to their canonical slide, HTML, PDF and
narration hashes. Tara's playback explanation and Arete's check-in comparison
were inspected in desktop, compact desktop, full-height mobile, embedded
desktop/mobile initial viewports and actual PDF page renders. Arete also has a
mobile table-end view. The mobile embedded capture is only the initial viewport;
it does not establish a full-scroll review on its own. Notes and questions were
reviewed for both slides. No material defect was found in these inspected
states; the final all-slide visual and normal-speed listening reviews remain
open. Repository Playwright, axe and Poppler supplied the available browser,
accessibility and PDF workflow; no dedicated presentation/PDF skill or
audio-listening tool was available.

## Source fidelity

The [member learning map](../../drafts/member-learning-map.md) records the
review and remaining source depth. Two new
[hash-bound assignments](../../assignments/member-playback-and-checkin.json)
cover the complete reviewed source units:

- Tara's playback policy always rejects non-finite values. Clamping only admits
  finite out-of-range requests. Corrected notes retain every policy field and
  demonstrate snapping, default rejection, explicit clamping and unconditional
  infinity rejection against the pinned implementation.
- Arete's `miss` is an explicit check-in status, not an absent record. The
  corrected comparison preserves all five meanings, engagement bounds, reason
  requirements and shared treatment helpers.

Additional snapshot findings remain separate from reviewed teaching units:
Tara's code has seven modality families despite the feature prose's six-family
claim; PWA helper return values record a posted request, not durable queueing,
activation or server success. The worker-request tests use a fake worker and do
not establish a real browser-worker journey.

The frontend skill guided retention of the existing plain comparison columns and
table. Exact normalization cases stay in the explanation without crowding the
slide or introducing decorative motion. No app/service runtime behavior or live
provider acceptance is claimed by these presentation changes.

## Automated checks and reproduction

All **54 Python tests** and **22 Node tests** pass in
[the Python log](unit-tests.txt) and [the Node log](node-tests.txt). Nine new
Node regressions cover pinned Tara playback behavior, authored Arete status
semantics, the two mocked PWA request boundaries and the seven-family Tara
inventory. They do not execute a current member application or the complete
Arete persistence path.

Builder and teaching-inventory freshness, scoped Ruff/ESLint/Prettier and
whitespace checks pass in [the static log](static-checks.txt). The explicit
[teaching-completeness gate](teaching-incomplete.txt) exits 1 as expected: nine
reviewed units, 103,317 unassigned meaningful units and no invalid or stale
assignment errors. It is incomplete, not a passing global release gate.

The [receipt](checks.json) binds current artifacts, reports, logs, visual review
and relevant tools. It records the actual verification scope with all global
completion claims false. Historical receipts are retained as historical
checkpoints; their old artifact hashes are not evidence for the current bytes.

Use the configured Python environment and browser before reproducing:

```bash
python -m unittest discover -s tools/presentations/tests -p 'test_*.py'
node --test tools/presentations/tests/*.test.mjs
python tools/presentations/build-eve-oshun.py --check --preview
python tools/presentations/check-center-coverage.py --check
python tools/presentations/check-center-coverage.py --require-complete
```

The final command is intentionally incomplete at this checkpoint. Run browser
suites sequentially with the repository supervisor and no narrator, using
`node tools/presentations/tests/eve-oshun-deck.mjs --guide v1-web-pwa`, then
repeat with `--guide tara` and `--guide arete`; run
`node tools/presentations/tests/presentation-center.mjs --draft --ready-audio`
afterward. Export all center PDFs last so the report binds the delivered files.
Use separate temporary QA directories, `CHROME_CHANNEL=chromium` on this host,
and the resource checks required by `AGENTS.md`. The observed browser was
Chromium 148.0.7778.96 with Playwright 1.60.0 and axe 4.11.4.

For the current-audio subset, pass the audit's comma-separated `currentIds` to
`render-eve-oshun-narration.py --check --ids`. The unfiltered full-inventory
narration gate remains required after all pending tracks are finished.
