# Isis 3D studio — evidence and decision records, part 2

Part 1 is the record `docs/agents/isis-3d-studio-evidence.md` (Eve document `25fb428c-23ff-8eaf-88a8-290a0d6a1b37`), which holds T.00 to T.20 up to 2026-10-06. Entries from T.01.21 on are here. An entry says what was read or run, when, and what it showed; what was not done is said in the entry.

## T.01.21 — UniMate, its checkpoints and the data behind it (2026-10-06)

**What was asked.** Register UniMate (SIGGRAPH Asia 2026, arXiv 2609.05415) and every data source behind it before T.12.08, T.12.09 or T.12.10 reads them, each row with the revision that was read.

**What was read**, on 2026-10-06 from the Linux dev server, through public APIs and raw files. No checkpoint, motion, mesh or pack was downloaded, and nothing was run.

| Source | Revision read | What it says |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Code, `github.com/Friedrich-M/UniMate` | commit `004d787452e0bf8253d669d6e7b26c2064055cad` (main, pushed 2026-10-05T21:07:03Z) | `LICENSE`: MIT, Copyright (c) 2026 Linzhan Mou (sha256 `7d5d80d7…`); the GitHub licence API says MIT |
| Checkpoints, `huggingface.co/Linzhan/UniMate` | revision `66d5240b4c4aded70040a2d67df4af261084b6e7` (last modified 2026-10-05T20:28:01Z) | card metadata `license: cc-by-nc-4.0`; card text "Checkpoints: CC BY-NC 4.0. Code: MIT"; `LICENSE` is the CC BY-NC 4.0 text headed "UniMate pretrained checkpoints" |
| Dataset, `huggingface.co/datasets/Linzhan/UniML3D` | revision `d0f19d943038fb782a26c2a615bd9b3d4f3a8728` (2026-10-05T04:16:21Z) | `license: other`; "The sources keep their own terms; this repository does not relicense them"; what the project added is ODC-BY 1.0 |
| `Linzhan/Objaverse-XL-Rigged-Animated` | revision `a2afbb4e49be307d6f8bccdfcd4ee0ccce6ea0aa` (2026-09-07) | `NOTICE.md`: each object keeps the licence attached to it upstream; the mirror's own metadata is ODC-BY 1.0 |

**The decisions, as the checks compute them.**

| Subject | Row | Outcome | Reason |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| Code | models manifest, candidate `unimate`, dependency `unimate/unimate-src` | admitted (`pass`) | MIT at a pinned commit |
| Six checkpoints (`unimate_uniml3d_f60_v3`, `_v2`, `_v2_cross_attn`, `_v1_preview`, `unimate_mixamo_f60_v2`, `unimate_truebones_f60_v2`) | 18 artifact rows: each model's highest-step checkpoint, `config.json` and `dataset_stats.npy` | refused | `licence_non_commercial` on every row: CC BY-NC 4.0, which neither distribution tier admits |
| UniML3D metadata (captions, joint labels, facing pairs, categories, quality lists, index tables) | assets manifest, `uniml3d-annotations`, 54 files pinned by sha256 (23.1 MB) | admitted, `service` | ODC-BY 1.0, with its notice obligations recorded |
| Truebones ZOO clips (1,097) | `uniml3d-truebones-zoo-clips` | refused | terms not read, no bytes pinned, redistribution prohibited; provenance dispute recorded |
| Mixamo clips in UniML3D (2,317) | `uniml3d-mixamo-clips` | refused | Mixamo terms not read, as T.01.05 |
| Objaverse-XL clips in UniML3D (10,355) and the mirror of their assets | `uniml3d-objaverse-xl-clips`, `objaverse-xl-rigged-animated` | refused until selected | `licence_per_item`; T.12.08 resolves them clip by clip |

**Why the checkpoints are a refusal and not the T.01.18 outcome.** T.01.18 narrows a weight to `internal_only` when its training data does not clear. That rule is about training data. These weights are refused by their own licence: the check reports `licence_non_commercial` as a reason on each, and reports the training data separately as a restriction (14 of them across the six). A test sets the weights' licence to MIT in a copy of the manifest: the refusal goes and the training-data restriction stays, so the two are separate findings and the first is the one that refuses.

**Truebones ZOO.** The model card (revision above) says: "Third parties allege that some of its animal assets come from commercial games (among them Resident Evil, Skyrim, Bless Online and Conan Exiles). We have not verified these claims; until they are resolved, treat the provenance of the Truebones-trained models as unclear." Not verified here either. The row records the claim, who reports it, the card revision and that it is unverified. The pack's own terms were not read: its sales page answered HTTP 200 with 70 characters of text and no terms. The dataset card says the pack "may not be redistributed". The row's note says not to buy the pack to train on.

**What the sampling path loads and imports.** `python -m unimate.inference.sample --exp_dir <model>` reads `config.json`, the highest-step `checkpoints/checkpoint_step_*.pt` and `dataset_stats.npy` (`sample.py:164-180, 203, 634-636`), and encodes text with `google/flan-t5-base`, fetched with no revision (`t5.py:228-229`). The 59 Python files under `unimate/` were read for imports: 21 dependency rows. 18 pass. `spacy` (a version range), the spaCy model (a release URL with no hash) and `Motion` (a git default branch, and no licence file) are refused as floating, `Motion` also as `licence_unknown`. `dataset_stats.npy` is a pickled object array (`descr '|O'`), so it has no stated dtype and unpickles on load.

**Checks.**

- `three-d-model-admission.ts --verify-remote`: 31 repository revisions read, 0 mismatches; `unimate` refused with `licence_non_commercial` 18, `precision_unknown` 12, `revision_floating` 9, `closure_incomplete` 6, `licence_unknown` 1; outcome `blocked`, gap C7 owned by T.12.08 and T.12.10.
- `three-d-asset-admission.ts`: 27 rows, 9 admitted as `service`, 18 refused.
- `libs/isis/workflows`, `src/three-d-capabilities`: 474 passed, 5 skipped. Seven new cases: each checkpoint refused by the weights' licence and not by training data; the code row admitted; the card pinned with a re-read date; the metadata row read as ODC-BY 1.0; a Truebones-derived clip refused, and refused on redistribution too if it were bundled; a Mixamo clip refused; the Objaverse-XL rows left to T.12.08.
- `libs/isis/3d-asset-library`, `license-assignment-registry.spec.ts`: 27 passed. Four of the new rows are ones that library cannot express; it reads them as `unknown`, never wider.

**Re-read by 2026-11-06.** The card went from v1 to v3 between 2026-09-27 and 2026-10-05 and gained the Truebones statement after release; the code repository's licence line changed on 2026-10-05. The pins and the date are on the candidate (`upstreamReview`).

**Not done.** The checkpoints' stored precision was not read (they are refused by licence). The frozen T5 encoder has no row. The Mixamo and Truebones terms remain unread. The mirror to `lilith-v1-5:R21` is a note on that task with these decisions; its rows are that task's to write.

Records: `docs/audits/isis-3d-unimate-T.01.21/2026-10-06/` (`reads.json`, `model-admission.txt`, `asset-admission.txt`, `specs.txt`).
