Eve library

Eve SOTA execution isolation — `eve.execution-isolation.v1`, record of 2026-10

Audit

Revision 38

On this page
  • Task: 2.6
  • Evaluated: 2026-10-10, revision 13
  • Decision: execution-isolation-measured-awaiting-independent-acceptance
  • ADR gate: execution-isolation (docs/adr/ADR-0076-eve-governed-delivery-lifecycle.md)
  • Record digest: 1e761ae6f8bf77ddbf1fd81766ea7e34c0adc7e84113c6bba45243d9b5116ff3

The rule#

This candidate records passing synthetic boundary regressions for the eight controls task 2.6 names; it does not assert independent acceptance or close task 2.6. At invocation startup the drain admits its workspace, tree, upstream state, identity, command root, child environment and initial destination. Immediately before every child, after establishing its item branch, fresh branch and tree admissions are required and checkpointed; tracked edits, untracked residue or an unreadable tree prevent that child and verification. Clean sequential committed work remains admitted. Other startup observations are not represented as per-child re-admissions, and drain-owned egress is checked before each authenticated request. Artifact and captured secret-output observations are evaluated after each executed item. Before saved-state reset, writing, orphan reaping, child work or verification, resume checks the recorded startup and per-child admission fields described below against the current invocation policy, as well as complete affirmative artifact/secret aftermath for every retained executed attempt. Missing, unknown-version or contradictory evidence in those checked fields withholds verification even if another item advanced on the ledger. The unchanged genuine R7 producer checkpoint is refused because it lacks required per-child admission; unsupported historical checkpoints require a separately admitted new run. The same requirement is checked immediately before the verify request on fresh and resumed paths. A documented unspawned resource hold is the only attempt allowed without child aftermath. Repeated refused resumes preserve the original checkpoint bytes, and fully measured benign work can resume without replay. These are local saved observations, not an integrity seal or a sandbox; the limits below bound this measurement.

The decisions and their refusal codes are read out of the isolation module. A control is credited only with regressions that ran and passed when this record was built; their outcomes are in the record, and its verifier runs them again against today’s checkout. No control is credited because a string appears in a source file.

The eight controls#

Control Decision Refuses with Enforced at
branch/worktree isolation admitCheckout, admitItemBranch workspace_branch_protected, workspace_branch_unexpected, workspace_shared, workspace_unknown Before any spawn, from git’s own answers about the repository under drain; and again per item, after the item’s derived branch is checked out.
dirty-tree protection admitTreeState tree_dirty, tree_unknown, tree_untracked_residue At invocation startup and again immediately before every child, from fresh tracked/untracked Git observations after the item branch is established. A refused or unreadable tree is checkpointed and prevents that child and verification; residue is preserved.
remote-divergence handling admitRemoteState remote_behind, remote_unknown At invocation startup, from the ahead and behind counts against the upstream; remote state is not re-admitted between children.
scoped credentials scopeChildEnvironment credential_absent, credential_overscoped At the spawn: the child is given the allowlisted environment the gate built, never the drain’s own.
allowed command roots admitCommandRoot command_root_escape, command_root_undeclared The drain passes the repository under drain to the harness as --repo; the harness roots Codex there (-C and the working directory) and refuses a --repo that is not a worktree’s top level.
network/secret policy admitEgress, admitReply, admitSecretCredentials, findSecretLeak, admitItemAftermath disclosure_unscanned, egress_host_not_allowed, egress_redirect_refused, egress_scheme_not_allowed, secret_unscannable, secret_would_leak Egress: in the one function through which the drain reaches the workbench, and in the harness’s, before every request; a reply that redirects is refused there and its destination is not contacted. Secrets: the workbench token is refused before any request when it is too short to scan for; the trimmed value the processes send is what is looked for, on the agent’s stdout and stderr as they arrive, and on the run record and the diagnostics the drain and the harness write; malformed successful JSON responses produce a body-free parse failure. Decoded successful metadata is scanned before use; owned output is guarded across writes, and child arguments and prompts are checked before execution. Error bodies are withheld before truncation. One final guard per output stream receives both drain-owned writes and forwarded child writes in order; findings are collected after the post-child outcome line and before verification. Resume checks the required recorded startup and per-child admissions, refusal arrays, allowlisted grants and output guard metadata as well as positive aftermath before reset or reaping. The same recorded consistency invariant is checked immediately before verification; refused or incomplete checked evidence withholds verification.
artifact ceilings admitArtifacts artifact_bytes_exceeded, artifact_count_exceeded, artifact_path_escape, artifact_unmeasured After each item: the drain measures every blob a commit since the item’s base introduced and every staged blob by the size of the object git holds, and every modified or untracked file by its size on disk, takes the largest reading per path, resolves recorded symlink chains in their original Git tree or index and worktree links component by component, refuses unresolved targets or cycles, adds a link target outside the repository, and judges that list against the repository root and the ceilings. New or changed direct gitlinks are unmeasured and refused, including intermediate and merge-only evidence, whether their target exists locally or not; unchanged baseline entries and their removal add no contents. Resume checks recorded safe count/total against current aggregate ceilings and refuses missing/contradictory checked startup or per-child admission, saved artifact refusal or incomplete aftermath before reset or reaping. Every executed retained attempt must have complete affirmative artifact and secret observations before verification. Historical artifacts are not remeasured by the retained guard.
separate implementer/verifier identity admitIdentitySeparation identity_not_separated Before any spawn, on the agent identity the drain will present; the verifier’s half is the BFF’s.

All 24 declared refusal codes are produced by one of the 8 controls.

The regressions this record ran#

Runner: node --test --test-concurrency=1 --test-reporter=tap <spec>, one process per proof file; final counts include nested cases.

Proof file Tests Passed Failed Skipped
tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs 35 35 0 0
tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs 50 50 0 0
tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs 6 6 0 0
tools/eve-runner-response.spec.mjs 5 5 0 0
tools/eve-fleet-merge-artifacts.spec.mjs 3 3 0 0
tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs 16 16 0 0
tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs 19 19 0 0
tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs 10 10 0 0
tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs 33 33 0 0
tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs 67 67 0 0
tools/eve-fleet-drain-interitem-tree.test.mjs 4 4 0 0

The 124 regressions below are the ones the controls are credited with. Each ran and passed when this record was built.

Control Regression In Outcome
branch/worktree isolation "real resume refuses an unchanged R7 checkpoint that committed inherited tracked residue" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
branch/worktree isolation "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
branch/worktree isolation "a full drain run refuses a shared checkout, a dirty tree, a checkout behind its remote, a missing credential and a verifier-shaped identity before any agent starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
branch/worktree isolation "a full drain run through the real harness roots Codex at the repository under drain, not at the tool’s checkout" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
dirty-tree protection "real resume refuses an unchanged R7 checkpoint that committed inherited tracked residue" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
dirty-tree protection "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
dirty-tree protection "a full drain run refuses a shared checkout, a dirty tree, a checkout behind its remote, a missing credential and a verifier-shaped identity before any agent starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
dirty-tree protection "real drain refuses tracked tree state before a later item starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain-interitem-tree.test.mjs passed
dirty-tree protection "real drain refuses untracked tree state before a later item starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain-interitem-tree.test.mjs passed
dirty-tree protection "real drain refuses unknown tree state before a later item starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain-interitem-tree.test.mjs passed
dirty-tree protection "real drain permits clean sequential committed work without inherited residue" tools/eve-fleet-drain-interitem-tree.test.mjs passed
remote-divergence handling "a full drain run refuses a shared checkout, a dirty tree, a checkout behind its remote, a missing credential and a verifier-shaped identity before any agent starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
remote-divergence handling "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
scoped credentials "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
scoped credentials "a full drain run refuses a shared checkout, a dirty tree, a checkout behind its remote, a missing credential and a verifier-shaped identity before any agent starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
scoped credentials "a spawned agent receives the scoped environment, never this process's own" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
allowed command roots "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
allowed command roots "a full drain run through the real harness roots Codex at the repository under drain, not at the tool’s checkout" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
allowed command roots "with two distinct checkouts, Codex is rooted at the one named, not the one the harness lives in" tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs passed
allowed command roots "a --repo that is not a worktree’s top level is refused before anything is contacted" tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real resume refuses an unchanged R7 checkpoint that committed inherited tracked residue" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real resource hold resumes without replaying an agent or buying a new item budget" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real drain retains secret refusal and withholds verification on repeated resume" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real drain resumes fully measured benign work without replaying its agent" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real drain withholds verification when an interrupted second agent has no aftermath" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real stdout combines the item banner and child exit tail before admission" tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real stdout combines the item banner and child chunks before admission" tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real stderr combines drain diagnostics and child exit tail before admission" tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "real stderr combines drain diagnostics and child chunks before admission" tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "child forwarding cannot release before a buffered banner and assemble a reordered secret" tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "benign child output and graceful stop keep stream order and normal verification" tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a child tail completed by the drain outcome line refuses verification and records the finding" tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "list refuses decoded credential-bearing metadata before output or agent execution" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "harness-dry refuses decoded credential-bearing metadata before output or agent execution" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "harness-live refuses decoded credential-bearing metadata before output or agent execution" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "drain-dry refuses decoded credential-bearing metadata before output or agent execution" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "drain-live refuses decoded credential-bearing metadata before output or agent execution" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "listing guards a secret assembled across separate output writes" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "agent arguments cannot smuggle an environment credential into a child prompt or argv" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a guarded dry-run print refusal removes the private credential profile" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "drain-owned dry-run output withholds credentials from configuration too" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "list preserves clean work-item behavior" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "harness-dry preserves clean work-item behavior" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "harness-live preserves clean work-item behavior" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "drain-live preserves clean work-item behavior" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "the client also refuses decoded nested values, property names and numeric credentials" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "the exported client withholds its own accepted token in error diagnostics without an extra secret map" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "error truncation happens after withholding, so it cannot expose most of a long credential" tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "eve-codex-agent.mjs refuses malformed successful JSON without disclosing its sent token" tools/eve-runner-response.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "eve-fleet-drain.mjs refuses malformed successful JSON without disclosing its sent token" tools/eve-runner-response.spec.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a redirect from the workbench is not followed: the destination it names receives nothing" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a redirect from the workbench is not followed: where it points receives no request and no token" tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a redirect is refused wherever it points, and its destination is reported without being contacted" tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "the token is guarded as it is sent: a padded one is withheld from error text, and a short one is never sent" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "the token is guarded as it is sent: a padded one never appears in an error, and a short one is never sent" tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a secret credential too short to scan for is refused, by name, and never used" tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "the guard looks for the credential as it is used: a padded token is caught trimmed" tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a full drain run sends nothing at all to a destination the egress policy refuses" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a refused destination is never requested, and an admitted one carries the agent identity" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a destination the egress policy refuses is never sent the token; loopback is" tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a full drain run stops at an item that prints the token: nothing after it, no verify, no token on disk" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "an agent that prints a credential is cut off at the secret and its group is ended" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "a secret that straddles two chunks of output is caught, and nothing after it is released" tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs passed
network/secret policy "an error reply that echoes the token is reported with the token withheld" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real resume refuses an unchanged R7 checkpoint that committed inherited tracked residue" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real resource hold resumes without replaying an agent or buying a new item budget" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real drain retains artifact refusal and withholds verification on repeated resume" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real drain resumes fully measured benign work without replaying its agent" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real drain withholds verification when an interrupted second agent has no aftermath" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "only an explicitly unspawned resource hold requires no aftermath" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "staged introduced gitlink with a missing target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "staged updated gitlink with a missing target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed introduced gitlink with a missing target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed updated gitlink with a missing target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "staged introduced gitlink with a local target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "staged updated gitlink with a local target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed introduced gitlink with a local target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed updated gitlink with a local target refuses measurement" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "staged removal of a baseline missing-target gitlink remains measured" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed removal of a baseline missing-target gitlink remains measured" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "staged removal of a baseline local-target gitlink remains measured" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed removal of a baseline local-target gitlink remains measured" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "historical missing-target gitlink refuses after being removed" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "historical missing-target gitlink refuses after being replaced" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "historical local-target gitlink refuses after being removed" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "historical local-target gitlink refuses after being replaced" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "an unchanged baseline missing-target gitlink does not block ordinary artifacts" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "an unchanged baseline local-target gitlink does not block ordinary artifacts" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a merge-only gitlink still refuses after a later commit removes it" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "the real drain refuses staged gitlink evidence" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "the real drain refuses committed gitlink evidence" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "the real drain refuses historical-removed gitlink evidence" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "the real drain refuses historical-replaced gitlink evidence" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "the real drain admits remove-staged gitlink evidence" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "the real drain admits remove-committed gitlink evidence" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "the real drain admits unchanged gitlink evidence" tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed then deleted file link follows the baseline chain outside" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed then deleted directory link follows the baseline chain outside" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed then deleted relative link follows the baseline chain outside" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "committed then deleted dotdot link follows the baseline chain outside" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "historical resolution uses the chain at that commit after an intermediate link is restored" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "staged link chains are measured from the index even after the worktree hides them" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a dangling worktree chain outside is refused without a realpath result" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "historical cycle evidence fails closed instead of claiming containment" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "historical missing evidence fails closed instead of claiming containment" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "clean internal chains and directory links remain admitted after deletion" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real drain withholds verification for a removed historical outside chain" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "real drain withholds verification for a removed historical cycle chain" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a merge-only chain survives later deletion and resolves in the merge tree" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "internal absolute links and parent components resolve after directory aliases" tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a merge-only oversized blob still closes the real drain gate after later delete" tools/eve-fleet-merge-artifacts.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a merge-only oversized blob still closes the real drain gate after later replace" tools/eve-fleet-merge-artifacts.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a merge does not count an unchanged large first-parent baseline as new work" tools/eve-fleet-merge-artifacts.spec.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a committed or staged file is measured by the object git holds, whatever the worktree says afterwards" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a full drain run stops at an item that writes outside the repository through a link, and at one over its ceiling" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "a full drain run admits an item whose output and artifacts are inside its isolation" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "what an item produced is measured from git: commits, worktree changes, deletions and where a symlink lands" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "what was not measured is refused, never assumed small or absent" tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs passed
artifact ceilings "before a spawn the artifact and secret controls are deferred, not reported as passed" tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs passed
separate implementer/verifier identity "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger" tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs passed
separate implementer/verifier identity "a full drain run refuses a shared checkout, a dirty tree, a checkout behind its remote, a missing credential and a verifier-shaped identity before any agent starts" tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs passed
separate implementer/verifier identity "the verifier prefix is the one the BFF actually enforces" tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs passed

The decision-level cases, one per control, are in the same files:

  • branch/worktree isolation: "an agent is refused the primary checkout and every protected branch"
  • dirty-tree protection: "tracked changes and untracked residue refuse separately"
  • remote-divergence handling: "behind refuses, ahead does not, and unknown refuses differently"
  • scoped credentials: "the child inherits only what was named, and secrets are counted as withheld"
  • allowed command roots: "a sibling directory sharing a prefix is not inside the root"
  • network/secret policy: "the workbench loopback is reachable while the internet is not"
  • artifact ceilings: "artifact ceilings bound count, total bytes, and single-file bytes"
  • separate implementer/verifier identity: "an implementer can never wear the verifier prefix, and the two must differ"

The refused revision#

docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-05.r8.json (record digest c6ee6b21f7c90b7cf4413f89379668cc72d5c4c2f68c9cdf9a51b0f8f55d3a9d, file SHA-256 c76a125dd51ed69519d510b82a6d2bce3cc91b004dba50ab0204763bd9ce4145) was refused by independent review 6fa86693-a335-483b-a3e2-f219ef6311e3 and was never selected. It is retained as it is, and it names the revision refused before it. What the review found, and what answers it here:

  • retained startup and per-child admission consistency. R8 accepted contradictory startup refusal/control records and missing or refused child branch/tree admissions, then rewrote checkpoints and requested verification. Answered by: "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger".
  • retained artifact aggregate ceilings. R8 accepted safe numeric artifact counts and byte totals exceeding the current invocation policy despite claiming retained consistency checks. Answered by: "real drain refuses missing or contradictory retained measurements despite an advanced ledger".
  • unchanged legacy checkpoint without per-child admission. The genuine R7 producer accepted a second child that committed inherited tracked residue; its unchanged checkpoint lacked the later per-child evidence and R8 resumed and verified it. Answered by: "real resume refuses an unchanged R7 checkpoint that committed inherited tracked residue".
  • exact unspawned resource hold remains usable. A retained admission repair must preserve a genuinely unspawned resource hold without replaying measured work, buying another budget, or admitting ambiguous executed attempts. Answered by: "real resource hold resumes without replaying an agent or buying a new item budget".

Honest limits#

  • Dirty-tree admission is a Git observation at invocation startup and immediately before each child, not a filesystem lock or sandbox. Residue left by an earlier child is preserved and refuses the next child; it is not cleaned or committed on that child’s behalf. A concurrent change after observation and before spawn is not prevented by these checks. Ignored files do not appear in Git status. Upstream/identity/root/environment startup admission is not repeated merely because the per-item observation also reads workspace metadata.
  • This candidate closes no task and makes no blanket enforcement or acceptance claim. It adds no provider-free orchestrator model or parity proof (2.7) and no live drain or soak result (2.8). No real Codex run is part of its proof: the regressions use an agent double and a codex double, and say so.
  • The drain does not sandbox the agent. It decides the environment the child receives, the repository and branch it is started in, the root Codex is given, and what happens after the child exits. Codex’s own sandbox is what confines the agent’s file writes and network while it runs; this record makes no claim about that sandbox.
  • Artifacts are measured from git in the repository under drain. A committed or staged file counts by the size of the object git holds, read from every commit since the item’s base, including each merge compared with its first parent, so replacing, deleting or later removing the file does not shrink it; a modified or untracked file counts by its size on disk; a path counts once, at its largest reading. Symlink chains are resolved from their original Git tree or index, or by component-wise worktree inspection. Missing symlink targets, unreadable evidence and chains beyond 40 links fail closed as unmeasured. New or changed direct gitlinks fail closed even when their target object exists locally, including index entries, commits, intermediate history and merge-only changes. An unchanged baseline gitlink or its removal adds no new contents and remains admitted; no submodule is fetched or executed. This can refuse a legitimate dangling link; it does not assume containment from absent evidence. A write outside the repository that leaves no trace in the repository or its history is not seen. Files git ignores are not listed by git status and are not measured unless they were committed or staged.
  • The artifact and secret controls are judged after the agent has run. They stop the drain and withhold the verify call; they do not undo what the agent did. An item the agent already moved on the ledger stays where the agent put it, and the run record says both.
  • Retained checkpoints are mutable local JSON observations, not signed or sealed receipts. The startup guard requires matching version, admitted true, an empty refusal array, seven true startup controls, artifacts deferred with exactly artifacts/secrets, unique granted names within the union of credential and process-environment allowlists with required names present, a nonnegative withheld-name count, one absolute command root matching the current invocation, checkout booleans and primary-worktree consistency, a nonempty branch, and either unknown-null upstream counts or safe nonnegative ahead with behind zero. GrantedCredentialNames includes process environment names; withheldCredentialCount is only a recorded nonnegative count, not a reconstructed secret inventory.
  • Each retained executed child needs matching-version affirmative preSpawnIsolation with clear refusal arrays and affirmative branch/tree controls, with trackedChangeCount and untrackedCount both zero. Existing aftermath checks require both controls admitted, no refusals or measurement errors, finite ordered process timestamps, a measured Git base, safe artifact count/total and guarded output metadata including required guard names. Count and total must meet the actual policy ceilings; total must also fit count multiplied by the single-file ceiling. These aggregate checks reject impossible totals; they do not remeasure historical paths, blobs or a largest file, authenticate timestamps or task identity, or prove the recorded branch/checkboxes describe what really happened.
  • The guard has no cryptographic binding or independent witness. A wholly rewritten affirmative checkpoint with internally consistent checked fields may be accepted; arbitrary additional fields are not all semantically validated. Refusal preserves checkpoint bytes, attributable Git state and child artifacts, but does not undo earlier agent activity or infer an interrupted aftermath from the ledger. Unsupported legacy evidence needs a separately admitted new run, never a retrospective repair to the failed checkpoint.
  • The resource-hold exception is the exact recorded shape: agent null, outcome not-observed, exit code and signal null, a nonempty resourceCheckpoint.refusals array, and absent preSpawnIsolation and aftermath isolation. The real resource-gated run and six ambiguous variants are exercised. It consumes the original item budget and does not replay measured work. The guard does not authenticate historical resource observations or semantically validate every resource refusal element; this is an exemption for recorded unspawned shape, not proof that no process could have run.
  • The secret guard compares against values the drain holds, trimmed as they are used: the workbench token and every variable in its own environment whose name reads as a secret. A workbench token shorter than eight characters is refused before any request, because the scanner does not look for values that short. Any other secret-named variable shorter than eight characters is not looked for and is not refused: it is withheld from the child by the environment allowlist, and that is its only protection. A secret the drain never learned the value of cannot be found, and neither can one that has been transformed (encoded, separated by extra bytes or reversed). Decoded JSON transport escapes are checked as metadata values; arbitrary encoded or transformed child output is not decoded. The drain guards captured agent stdout and stderr, and the drain and harness guard their own output. Final stdout and stderr guards combine drain-owned and forwarded child writes in stream order, including the post-child outcome; splitting a known value across writes on the same stream is covered. Separate stdout and stderr streams are not combined. The harness alone does not intercept inherited child stdio; when invoked by the drain, that output is captured by the drain. The guard does not cover what the agent writes into files or sends through its own MCP session.
  • The egress control governs the requests the drain and the harness make. A reply that redirects is refused, wherever it points, and the request is not sent again; a workbench that legitimately redirects cannot be drained. The MCP server the harness hands Codex makes its own requests to the same workbench URL; it is only started after the gate has admitted that URL, and its requests, and any redirect it follows, are not checked here. The control installs no firewall.
  • The implementer and verifier control enforces the half the drain owns: the identity it presents can never be verifier-shaped. The verifier’s identity is the BFF’s to derive and enforce.
  • The branch derived for an item is checked immediately before the spawn. A branch changed by something else during the run is not re-checked until the next item.

What this record supersedes#

  • Predecessor: docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-09-05.json, evaluated 2026-09-05, record digest d46371c0f9efa4d86a2695b382456309df500b52f5953ac124405337cbf48176, file SHA-256 6aef700d020ec7a77d5230e2347779654188917c7de3f68377ba37354380fd74.
  • Its readable record: docs/audits/EVE_SOTA_EXECUTION_ISOLATION_2026-09.md, pinned at revision 1 (SHA-256 7e62b18dcd88e4809d8adc8f9cbd9b49d26dd92ea8910da64caddbfb8606323d).

Sources the 2026-09-05 record hashed have changed since it was made, and the drain it describes has changed: after review 1548bce3 the command root, the artifact and secret controls and the egress check are enforced at different places than that record says, and after review b6600df1 a redirect is refused, committed and staged files are measured by the objects git holds, and the token is guarded as it is sent. After independent review 90e41339, decoded successful metadata and owned streams withhold credentials; historical symlink chains resolve against their original trees and unknown containment is refused. After review 09805e73, a final shared guard covers drain and child writes in stream order through the post-child outcome, and direct new or changed gitlinks refuse admission even when locally resolvable. Earlier malformed-response, merge-maximum, successful-metadata and historical-symlink protections remain exercised. After review f05f77ce, resume preserves saved refusal, requires affirmative complete aftermath for every retained executed attempt and rechecks that invariant before verification. After reviewer ddf58389 and delegate142c302d rejected R7’s startup-only dirty-tree description, tree admission now runs again before each child with tracked, untracked, unreadable-tree and clean sequential controls. This candidate is derived from the source measured on 2026-10-10 after those changes, the shared readable-pin fixture repair, the change to an explicit source manifest, and that manifest widened to every module the derivation and its verifiers import; independent acceptance and task2.6 closure remain withheld.

Hashed sources that differ from the predecessor’s#

Source Bucket Change Predecessor This record
EVE_SOTA_GAP_CLOSURE_TODOS_2026-09-01.md authoritative requirements differ 094c5f944f10 3dcdbb8440a0
tools/eve-execution-isolation-lib.mjs authoritative bytes differ 7be6a7e29f8f d6c9c0839291
tools/eve-fleet-drain.mjs authoritative bytes differ b682d5436983 771d1f1ab791
tools/eve-fleet-drain-lib.mjs authoritative bytes differ c62dfa148344 c03a0dee166b
apps/oshun/bff/src/workbench/intent-store.ts authoritative bytes differ 36a7f1f17036 c2c78370706e
tools/eve-codex-agent-lib.mjs authoritative bytes differ 637d6b36eadc bfd32a9bc2a1
tools/eve-codex-agent.mjs authoritative newly hashed none fd4f5e75e456
tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs proof bytes differ 3cff6eb5b13d c7e54d6df9bb
tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs proof bytes differ 17bb2215cc94 323bdc60a535
tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs proof newly hashed none 26a45d370118
tools/eve-runner-response.spec.mjs proof newly hashed none 6843936438e1
tools/eve-fleet-merge-artifacts.spec.mjs proof newly hashed none 84f1da544128
tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs proof newly hashed none 5d17a039ab9f
tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs proof newly hashed none 96ce9e6a133c
tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs proof newly hashed none aea3192466c2
tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs proof newly hashed none 6a410acfa39a
tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs proof newly hashed none 248d3ea79471
tools/eve-fleet-drain-interitem-tree.test.mjs proof newly hashed none 8560f9a23cd9
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation.schema.json implementation no longer hashed none none
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation.mjs implementation bytes differ e114beba5826 5617dad54e45
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation.mjs implementation bytes differ 41adc1e3fdd2 11222a1cecb3
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation.test.mjs implementation no longer hashed none none
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-05.r9.schema.json implementation newly hashed none 9e81da046aa6
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r9.mjs implementation newly hashed none a634f01cceae
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r9.mjs implementation newly hashed none b42f6ddb2bd6
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-06.r10.schema.json implementation newly hashed none 0c43d80128c8
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-06-r10.mjs implementation newly hashed none 5884f4ad86b7
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-06-r10.mjs implementation newly hashed none 78d56fdb14d0
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-07.r11.schema.json implementation newly hashed none fa8b3f2132a8
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-07-r11.mjs implementation newly hashed none bbe0afb795ef
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-07-r11.mjs implementation newly hashed none acbc5d32786f
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-10.r13.schema.json implementation newly hashed none e20f14433c59
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation newly hashed none 95462e6bf987
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation newly hashed none 5b738d069f08
tools/yemaya-study/json-schema-subset.mjs implementation newly hashed none e0c79b754d83
tools/eve-everywhere/record-sources.mjs implementation newly hashed none e3a0a3c4c58c
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation newly hashed none 0346c55416d9
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation newly hashed none bf701fb313db
tools/eve-everywhere/gap-task-dependencies.mjs implementation newly hashed none ed5a74699326
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation newly hashed none 44b8035cd9ba
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation newly hashed none a5540b3d31f6
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation newly hashed none 2de2167709b3
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation newly hashed none 9094646755df
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation newly hashed none cd25b414f3cf
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation newly hashed none d7fe85973f6c
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation newly hashed none 6988949dcc3c
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation newly hashed none f5c1e3466550
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation newly hashed none db72e85d8cbe
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation newly hashed none e35c4ce28ded
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation newly hashed none ffb064c67693
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation newly hashed none c1c7efab51a6

Derived values that differ from the predecessor’s#

50 derived values differ. Each is listed with the predecessor’s value and this record’s; every other value is the predecessor’s.

  • controls.allowed-command-roots.boundaryProof: absent → 611 characters, in the record
  • controls.allowed-command-roots.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.allowed-command-roots.enforcedAt: absent → 193 characters, in the record
  • controls.artifact-ceilings.boundaryProof: absent → 7591 characters, in the record
  • controls.artifact-ceilings.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.artifact-ceilings.enforcedAt: absent → 1115 characters, in the record
  • controls.artifact-ceilings.produces: ["artifact_bytes_exceeded","artifact_count_exceeded","artifact_path_escape"] → 98 characters, in the record
  • controls.branch-worktree-isolation.boundaryProof: absent → 700 characters, in the record
  • controls.branch-worktree-isolation.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.branch-worktree-isolation.enforcedAt: absent → 142 characters, in the record
  • controls.dirty-tree-protection.boundaryProof: absent → 1078 characters, in the record
  • controls.dirty-tree-protection.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.dirty-tree-protection.enforcedAt: absent → 256 characters, in the record
  • controls.implementer-verifier-identity.boundaryProof: absent → 496 characters, in the record
  • controls.implementer-verifier-identity.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.implementer-verifier-identity.enforcedAt: absent → 97 characters, in the record
  • controls.network-and-secret-policy.boundaryProof: absent → 6386 characters, in the record
  • controls.network-and-secret-policy.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.network-and-secret-policy.decisions: ["admitEgress","findSecretLeak"] → 91 characters, in the record
  • controls.network-and-secret-policy.enforcedAt: absent → 1260 characters, in the record
  • controls.network-and-secret-policy.produces: ["egress_host_not_allowed","egress_scheme_not_allowed","secret_would_leak"] → 145 characters, in the record
  • controls.remote-divergence-handling.boundaryProof: absent → 379 characters, in the record
  • controls.remote-divergence-handling.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.remote-divergence-handling.enforcedAt: absent → 127 characters, in the record
  • controls.scoped-credentials.boundaryProof: absent → 505 characters, in the record
  • controls.scoped-credentials.calledByDrain: true → absent
  • controls.scoped-credentials.enforcedAt: absent → 99 characters, in the record
  • decision.derivedNotDeclared: 256 characters, in the record → 326 characters, in the record
  • decision.statement: 439 characters, in the record → 1850 characters, in the record
  • decision.status: execution-isolation-enforced → execution-isolation-measured-awaiting-independent-acceptance
  • limitations: 1842 characters, in the record → 7491 characters, in the record
  • observedBaseline.boundaryRegressionCount: absent → 124
  • observedBaseline.drainSpecCases: 34 → 50
  • observedBaseline.harnessSpecCases: absent → 6
  • observedBaseline.identity.agentContractForbidsShippedAndVerified: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.identity.verifierPrefixEnforcedByStore: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.isolationSpecCases: 25 → 35
  • observedBaseline.refusalCodeCount: 20 → 24
  • observedBaseline.secrecy.scannerReportsNamesNotValues: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.secrecy.shortValuesAreNotScanned: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.wiring.agentNeverInheritsThisProcessEnvironment: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.wiring.commandRootBoundToTheRepository: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.wiring.gateRecordedOnTheRun: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.wiring.gateRefusesTheRun: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.wiring.isolationIsItsOwnStopReason: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.wiring.perItemBranchIsDerived: true → absent
  • observedBaseline.wiring.spawnTakesAScopedEnvironment: true → absent
  • outcome.closes: ["2.6"] → []
  • outcome.reason: 176 characters, in the record → 274 characters, in the record
  • refusalCodes: 451 characters, in the record → 543 characters, in the record

The sources this record hashed#

Source Bucket Digest of SHA-256
EVE_SOTA_GAP_CLOSURE_TODOS_2026-09-01.md authoritative task-requirements 3dcdbb8440a0691c66693b3db8472a6b151abd45cd5d6a38a41195b264d379cd
docs/adr/ADR-0076-eve-governed-delivery-lifecycle.md authoritative file-bytes 56c688b7f9f00603522f20f113129ff56225b59b2f4dd3f76aacabecf706514d
tools/eve-execution-isolation-lib.mjs authoritative file-bytes d6c9c0839291a62b04fbd0e54b4af234cc4e1b246f421766384ab1e32bcb34ea
tools/eve-fleet-drain.mjs authoritative file-bytes 771d1f1ab79111c294dd06119d288b7d6b50321922a2576d4a18e94baa56f34b
tools/eve-fleet-drain-lib.mjs authoritative file-bytes c03a0dee166bb33551a854dbf429c154afa3d2f00a3041e4282e2e75a5bf9276
apps/oshun/bff/src/workbench/intent-store.ts authoritative file-bytes c2c78370706eba24fe992beec5ccab682c7720f6f465d5895c4f57b5a0a9f16c
tools/eve-codex-agent-lib.mjs authoritative file-bytes bfd32a9bc2a17f415b8338d1ff4001de30904b0ad739e85573456b5ecfe6f4a2
tools/eve-codex-agent.mjs authoritative file-bytes fd4f5e75e45662615c8e2d22d99076ddf57cad6b02c8a6a5b50efb4bf8e4033b
tools/eve-execution-isolation.test.mjs proof file-bytes c7e54d6df9bb14b2ea40c88f0affeafe6865101c5e478f76c2959cb800f478b2
tools/eve-fleet-drain.test.mjs proof file-bytes 323bdc60a53588292711084e04fdd1f9638b0f9b8792acf974298cd0dca3deb1
tools/eve-codex-agent.test.mjs proof file-bytes 26a45d370118d5abc0bcbdefce1c2a1b25eacc9e4ed9c0502531ea5b51c7b943
tools/eve-runner-response.spec.mjs proof file-bytes 6843936438e1a106571e2596fc9e4ff97fe0cc364641e915fbe8bf68a089c771
tools/eve-fleet-merge-artifacts.spec.mjs proof file-bytes 84f1da54412862bed24bd9a1776cc7cb98a89b05a89a910c029dbd058381df5c
tools/eve-runner-metadata-guard.spec.mjs proof file-bytes 5d17a039ab9f816ceb0c31e6192fa4514789b3193a20d87df8d1e9993e5b3e56
tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs proof file-bytes 96ce9e6a133cd9377e633318afba8c3fe163dae88a51ccd3ff4dc35bc301cd93
tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs proof file-bytes aea3192466c253cce03d22682b9a80ec0ee76fd84be222c5aa5db1dc3634588d
tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs proof file-bytes 6a410acfa39ab9a12a8ff08d99c7fb00d07b404586078fe6fa46fff9ba323450
tools/eve-fleet-drain-resume-isolation.test.mjs proof file-bytes 248d3ea794712666d57832ba2eaf94f0c5179f876a7b9ca771a4192ea678f975
tools/eve-fleet-drain-interitem-tree.test.mjs proof file-bytes 8560f9a23cd9007dcf1a18a7c37db3902d1447c43294b3c58cecf0ed146672a9
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-05.r9.schema.json implementation file-bytes 9e81da046aa6a2bd7c4240ddf7837df238d48669d88d9690f3a130b2ee09bb6f
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation.mjs implementation file-bytes 5617dad54e45c05b1a02777828eacaf4a231909000027078fdec4fc9afa176a0
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r9.mjs implementation file-bytes a634f01cceae2a9854d9c5ab27ebdb63872d9d7e5383b07cc494fce24d1a5fe0
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r9.mjs implementation file-bytes b42f6ddb2bd621b30cfd4d903f7de168a6c27b09c9c5e87e5726ad8bb61269ac
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation.mjs implementation file-bytes 11222a1cecb3b1aa4b9276564fad567509b65e1176f13bebfa2c93620835094a
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-06.r10.schema.json implementation file-bytes 0c43d80128c893f1d9b8a06d80a30c98c2a88c98cb8eb5c7476766c753417888
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-06-r10.mjs implementation file-bytes 5884f4ad86b7192629b5a7391c101693231a121c80b5c910d0ac47b5242c73a0
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-06-r10.mjs implementation file-bytes 78d56fdb14d09a731e7b3c7ed0d3a44cd3b2f0aee9f40ced3e3c2d419432e2d5
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-07.r11.schema.json implementation file-bytes fa8b3f2132a8cfb2b9c342850f62ce68099477108b1f2552d58db326b522a6d7
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-07-r11.mjs implementation file-bytes bbe0afb795ef8c4e0a90bd2df390eb8399fd32ad17a6c2bab8ca1ab2c98e74cd
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-07-r11.mjs implementation file-bytes acbc5d32786f755611bc32a82d3c9f0c8a594a7fb2a67e67589fb2807f48005f
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-10.r13.schema.json implementation file-bytes e20f14433c594219e42423647df9b5f6d5a7ca226674823baa55c8d749cba17f
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation file-bytes 95462e6bf9877df02f206efbca8c026089c968b930e7f9b5e915d4318c9b2deb
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation file-bytes 5b738d069f08fec5708036546f4e775a06ec619c9db25f06ea0f315789e280d7
tools/yemaya-study/json-schema-subset.mjs implementation file-bytes e0c79b754d83318a427cd5c3e17763fea4a27ff5e93d83d29ae9177a88aa1174
tools/eve-everywhere/record-sources.mjs implementation file-bytes e3a0a3c4c58c8d528f01d992353b0f94ba72feea39c99ab93dc323bf85585897
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation file-bytes 0346c55416d95675c67aa88918bd209ba4e23391bc4599f0520c5a3026e4c268
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation file-bytes bf701fb313dbc3484d02db264eb8a68436afe3cd29497885e00549f086528988
tools/eve-everywhere/gap-task-dependencies.mjs implementation file-bytes ed5a7469932668463a771da53308fd4f1e34e6ebb0f36f544c702cbfda0e2131
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation file-bytes 44b8035cd9ba857c2ccf6e12debbba2b8109c819e796cdbd46033e0a125ee413
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation file-bytes a5540b3d31f678b0641942f24a4b887b3b0c372dba7f12f2ca6ae3eff4870c48
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation file-bytes 2de2167709b37705ad6ab6ca603aa3c58e00fee42282b1f774f04d1240150d54
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation file-bytes 9094646755dfbf3cc9ca1af8a6d4a60ac90e2f0635ef9d0b3cde1bd0f55e9ed0
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation file-bytes cd25b414f3cf18be268e1453bcd54dc971004acfe5e6f2497511b51887dc4bb4
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation file-bytes d7fe85973f6c4553796317065fbee1343852be43f69c07f4a0b4092bd1cd1c07
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation file-bytes 6988949dcc3c31db73d9baa4ae37112d83d853420dc10283abac514a654c4420
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation file-bytes f5c1e346655058fbb7b2698286ec9d9467a845dcf51ff2de1a5609657b507dba
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation file-bytes db72e85d8cbee69d06bc1acbd56c0bf5dc0666cb8aa89edea9d581aae14637dc
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation file-bytes e35c4ce28ded2c76e6f8010727cecc9e6c260f646b09208b478fe14ab1210179
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation file-bytes ffb064c6769337d1a1609f7ee547fd0d468d311a85c5b9e2ea54d261031ef3ad
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation file-bytes c1c7efab51a6206ed918d062116ea5ed645ec800269902809c565223753a28d4

Renewal of the approved tenth measurement#

Retained record: docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-06.r10.json; file SHA-256 03aaf3c8dde3f30a9fba835e5fcaa6bec8284af34bbe8caaef5ec1034bcf92ee; record digest d36db61b4f795e8b12b36453a64b5c81e5c4fff0d58422ffd4259336299c2cad. Approved readable document: 62f299ce-7a63-4dec-96c0-11d0e6c3336d@31, SHA-256 364660ba35c6ff214fe59d62ceb14a1d8749b8671ba334498aceaef69ed43bc8.

The approved R10 readable rendering remains unchanged, and R10 is not rewritten. Sources R10 bound changed after it was made, so its current applicability fails; among them is a regression test of a verifier, from which nothing about the drain is measured. By the scope decision of question 5ff0d411 a record binds its sources by an explicit manifest. This record binds by eve-sota-execution-isolation.sources.v2: the requirements, the runtime that enforces and wires the controls, the eleven executed proof files, the active schema, and every module that this record’s generator, its verifier and the shared verifier import, through any other, each whole. Verifier-only regression tests and the specs of records are left out, each named with its reason, and go on running as automated checks; the reader of repository files and the table of approved pins are left out as a boundary, each with its reason. All drain controls, boundary regressions, limitations and historical refusal findings remain retained, and the eleven boundary suites were run again for this record. This candidate is submitted for independent review; no new consumer pin, approval, Dev freeze or task 2.6 closure is asserted.

Source Bucket Change Previous SHA-256 Current SHA-256
tools/eve-fleet-drain.mjs authoritative bytes differ a86dbf0813485388d005a7855bc4206f07238abb9221252a06c0b0818b3acd4d 771d1f1ab79111c294dd06119d288b7d6b50321922a2576d4a18e94baa56f34b
apps/oshun/bff/src/workbench/intent-store.ts authoritative bytes differ 5e0e94417b398295386eaaaaffd42c2b0cecf759683259f3d48b66d9a52a9f15 c2c78370706eba24fe992beec5ccab682c7720f6f465d5895c4f57b5a0a9f16c
tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs proof bytes differ b44723619d8a0c431ce81b58aa74a1c564bed2aa5c9a04de13e090462b4b2729 96ce9e6a133cd9377e633318afba8c3fe163dae88a51ccd3ff4dc35bc301cd93
tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs proof bytes differ 2fe1c613a9ce85c330552fa0f01aba7fd214ea9b74c56f96f8951d7d4e52735f aea3192466c253cce03d22682b9a80ec0ee76fd84be222c5aa5db1dc3634588d
tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs proof bytes differ adc4dd304f8b474dfa118fcd4b4789b29bbd28c12a7bdd734deff456a481324c 6a410acfa39ab9a12a8ff08d99c7fb00d07b404586078fe6fa46fff9ba323450
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r9.spec.mjs implementation no longer hashed none none
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.spec.mjs implementation no longer hashed none none
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation.mjs implementation bytes differ fb2090350e769c8f0220630ef93f391af45c8a5e591776301950ea340a4088ff 11222a1cecb3b1aa4b9276564fad567509b65e1176f13bebfa2c93620835094a
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation.test.mjs implementation no longer hashed none none
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-cross-surface-execution-isolation.test.mjs implementation no longer hashed none none
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.test.mjs implementation no longer hashed none none
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-06-r10.spec.mjs implementation no longer hashed none none
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-07.r11.schema.json implementation newly hashed none fa8b3f2132a8cfb2b9c342850f62ce68099477108b1f2552d58db326b522a6d7
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-07-r11.mjs implementation newly hashed none bbe0afb795ef8c4e0a90bd2df390eb8399fd32ad17a6c2bab8ca1ab2c98e74cd
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-07-r11.mjs implementation newly hashed none acbc5d32786f755611bc32a82d3c9f0c8a594a7fb2a67e67589fb2807f48005f
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-10.r13.schema.json implementation newly hashed none e20f14433c594219e42423647df9b5f6d5a7ca226674823baa55c8d749cba17f
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation newly hashed none 95462e6bf9877df02f206efbca8c026089c968b930e7f9b5e915d4318c9b2deb
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation newly hashed none 5b738d069f08fec5708036546f4e775a06ec619c9db25f06ea0f315789e280d7
tools/yemaya-study/json-schema-subset.mjs implementation newly hashed none e0c79b754d83318a427cd5c3e17763fea4a27ff5e93d83d29ae9177a88aa1174
tools/eve-everywhere/record-sources.mjs implementation newly hashed none e3a0a3c4c58c8d528f01d992353b0f94ba72feea39c99ab93dc323bf85585897
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation newly hashed none 0346c55416d95675c67aa88918bd209ba4e23391bc4599f0520c5a3026e4c268
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation newly hashed none bf701fb313dbc3484d02db264eb8a68436afe3cd29497885e00549f086528988
tools/eve-everywhere/gap-task-dependencies.mjs implementation newly hashed none ed5a7469932668463a771da53308fd4f1e34e6ebb0f36f544c702cbfda0e2131
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation newly hashed none 44b8035cd9ba857c2ccf6e12debbba2b8109c819e796cdbd46033e0a125ee413
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation newly hashed none a5540b3d31f678b0641942f24a4b887b3b0c372dba7f12f2ca6ae3eff4870c48
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation newly hashed none 2de2167709b37705ad6ab6ca603aa3c58e00fee42282b1f774f04d1240150d54
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation newly hashed none 9094646755dfbf3cc9ca1af8a6d4a60ac90e2f0635ef9d0b3cde1bd0f55e9ed0
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation newly hashed none cd25b414f3cf18be268e1453bcd54dc971004acfe5e6f2497511b51887dc4bb4
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation newly hashed none d7fe85973f6c4553796317065fbee1343852be43f69c07f4a0b4092bd1cd1c07
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation newly hashed none 6988949dcc3c31db73d9baa4ae37112d83d853420dc10283abac514a654c4420
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation newly hashed none f5c1e346655058fbb7b2698286ec9d9467a845dcf51ff2de1a5609657b507dba
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation newly hashed none db72e85d8cbee69d06bc1acbd56c0bf5dc0666cb8aa89edea9d581aae14637dc
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation newly hashed none e35c4ce28ded2c76e6f8010727cecc9e6c260f646b09208b478fe14ab1210179
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation newly hashed none ffb064c6769337d1a1609f7ee547fd0d468d311a85c5b9e2ea54d261031ef3ad
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation newly hashed none c1c7efab51a6206ed918d062116ea5ed645ec800269902809c565223753a28d4

The eleventh candidate, returned by review#

Retained record: docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-07.r11.json; file SHA-256 88a7ad6eaba7a9feed9d6d80b7838c752115aea9b0f798a8476e0dd2fd4d062c; record digest c04f39436280391ecc761caab81988562746eec6512615af6853d46828278d0a; manifest eve-sota-execution-isolation.sources.v1. Readable document as submitted: 62f299ce-7a63-4dec-96c0-11d0e6c3336d@33, SHA-256 510facc1b633317ed36d5025d2d7efbf723c2217cc56c7efaf00f4522c4dcaf9; reviewed at commit 3df9de561110e6188f2d30a7f48d4062d56d90f3; never selected: true.

R11 was submitted for review and returned at this commit: its manifest found what to bind by generator file names, and so left out modules its verifiers import, the schema validator and the reader of the ledger’s task requirements among them. A change to one of those could alter what is checked and leave R11 reading as current. R11 is retained unchanged and was never selected; this record takes its place as the candidate. The sources below are what this record binds differently from R11: the modules newly bound, and the bound sources that have changed since R11 was made.

Source Bucket Change Previous SHA-256 Current SHA-256
tools/eve-fleet-drain.mjs authoritative bytes differ a86dbf0813485388d005a7855bc4206f07238abb9221252a06c0b0818b3acd4d 771d1f1ab79111c294dd06119d288b7d6b50321922a2576d4a18e94baa56f34b
tools/eve-fleet-historical-symlinks.spec.mjs proof bytes differ b44723619d8a0c431ce81b58aa74a1c564bed2aa5c9a04de13e090462b4b2729 96ce9e6a133cd9377e633318afba8c3fe163dae88a51ccd3ff4dc35bc301cd93
tools/eve-fleet-combined-output.spec.mjs proof bytes differ 2fe1c613a9ce85c330552fa0f01aba7fd214ea9b74c56f96f8951d7d4e52735f aea3192466c253cce03d22682b9a80ec0ee76fd84be222c5aa5db1dc3634588d
tools/eve-fleet-direct-gitlinks.spec.mjs proof bytes differ adc4dd304f8b474dfa118fcd4b4789b29bbd28c12a7bdd734deff456a481324c 6a410acfa39ab9a12a8ff08d99c7fb00d07b404586078fe6fa46fff9ba323450
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation.mjs implementation bytes differ ca08979658be3016035b997966fb9586ca6c8838d3ce8f8a19fe1c13bee7f805 11222a1cecb3b1aa4b9276564fad567509b65e1176f13bebfa2c93620835094a
docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-10.r13.schema.json implementation newly hashed none e20f14433c594219e42423647df9b5f6d5a7ca226674823baa55c8d749cba17f
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation newly hashed none 95462e6bf9877df02f206efbca8c026089c968b930e7f9b5e915d4318c9b2deb
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.mjs implementation newly hashed none 5b738d069f08fec5708036546f4e775a06ec619c9db25f06ea0f315789e280d7
tools/yemaya-study/json-schema-subset.mjs implementation newly hashed none e0c79b754d83318a427cd5c3e17763fea4a27ff5e93d83d29ae9177a88aa1174
tools/eve-everywhere/record-sources.mjs implementation newly hashed none e3a0a3c4c58c8d528f01d992353b0f94ba72feea39c99ab93dc323bf85585897
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation newly hashed none 0346c55416d95675c67aa88918bd209ba4e23391bc4599f0520c5a3026e4c268
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-gap-task-evidence-exit.mjs implementation newly hashed none bf701fb313dbc3484d02db264eb8a68436afe3cd29497885e00549f086528988
tools/eve-everywhere/gap-task-dependencies.mjs implementation newly hashed none ed5a7469932668463a771da53308fd4f1e34e6ebb0f36f544c702cbfda0e2131
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation newly hashed none 44b8035cd9ba857c2ccf6e12debbba2b8109c819e796cdbd46033e0a125ee413
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal.mjs implementation newly hashed none a5540b3d31f678b0641942f24a4b887b3b0c372dba7f12f2ca6ae3eff4870c48
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation newly hashed none 2de2167709b37705ad6ab6ca603aa3c58e00fee42282b1f774f04d1240150d54
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.mjs implementation newly hashed none 9094646755dfbf3cc9ca1af8a6d4a60ac90e2f0635ef9d0b3cde1bd0f55e9ed0
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation newly hashed none cd25b414f3cf18be268e1453bcd54dc971004acfe5e6f2497511b51887dc4bb4
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r5.mjs implementation newly hashed none d7fe85973f6c4553796317065fbee1343852be43f69c07f4a0b4092bd1cd1c07
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation newly hashed none 6988949dcc3c31db73d9baa4ae37112d83d853420dc10283abac514a654c4420
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r6.mjs implementation newly hashed none f5c1e346655058fbb7b2698286ec9d9467a845dcf51ff2de1a5609657b507dba
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation newly hashed none db72e85d8cbee69d06bc1acbd56c0bf5dc0666cb8aa89edea9d581aae14637dc
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r7.mjs implementation newly hashed none e35c4ce28ded2c76e6f8010727cecc9e6c260f646b09208b478fe14ab1210179
tools/eve-everywhere/generate-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation newly hashed none ffb064c6769337d1a1609f7ee547fd0d468d311a85c5b9e2ea54d261031ef3ad
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.mjs implementation newly hashed none c1c7efab51a6206ed918d062116ea5ed645ec800269902809c565223753a28d4

The twelfth candidate, not on main#

Record docs/audits/eve-sota-execution-isolation/2026-10-07.r12.json at commit 05d7a45f95f7c6ed66f12e90e4af805bd5c239bd, evaluated 2026-10-07, revision 12; file SHA-256 2c548531b13c439f8a2df308252be489566df2e69183ef7e9b98ee1ce16c0524; record digest 1a4f5b3a2596fbcba5b4bd7b39ea4fd72f8feb6bdc6e1e68f0dc3b1ec2672688; manifest eve-sota-execution-isolation.sources.v1. Readable document as submitted: 62f299ce-7a63-4dec-96c0-11d0e6c3336d@35, SHA-256 416c579974bb4207258a3025b1fcd57002c4363f20b20dbd308815c1c43b5158; landed on main: false; never selected: true.

A twelfth measurement was made on 2026-10-07 on the branch eve/main-tests-green/triage-callers-r12, together with a change to the drain (it presents its fencing token only for a lease still live when it judges), and was submitted as revision 35 of the readable document. Neither that change nor that record is on main: by the scope decision of question fbcfb4c4 they land only with an independently approved successor that covers the final sources. It binds by the first manifest, with the omission R11 was returned for, and main’s drain has changed since. This record does not measure that branch and does not replace what it must still show: when the drain change lands, the drain is measured again.

Source manifest eve-sota-execution-isolation.sources.v2#

Bound, each whole: 8 authoritative sources, 11 executed proof files and 31 implementation sources. Left out, with the reason:

Source Boundary Reason
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r9.spec.mjs no The spec of an earlier record: it judges that record, the derivation does not read it, and it goes on running as an automated check.
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05-r8.spec.mjs no The spec of an earlier record: it judges that record, the derivation does not read it, and it goes on running as an automated check.
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation.test.mjs no A regression test of the verifier and nothing else: it proves no drain control, the derivation does not read it, and it goes on running as an automated check.
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-cross-surface-execution-isolation.test.mjs no A regression test of the verifier and nothing else: it proves no drain control, the derivation does not read it, and it goes on running as an automated check.
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-05.test.mjs no The spec of an earlier record: it judges that record, the derivation does not read it, and it goes on running as an automated check.
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-06-r10.spec.mjs no The spec of an earlier record: it judges that record, the derivation does not read it, and it goes on running as an automated check.
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-07-r11.spec.mjs no The spec of an earlier record: it judges that record, the derivation does not read it, and it goes on running as an automated check.
tools/eve-everywhere/verify-execution-isolation-renewal-2026-10-10-r13.spec.mjs no The spec of this record: it judges this record and its verifier, the derivation does not read it, and it runs as an automated check. It was never bound.
tools/eve-everywhere/retired-inputs.mjs yes The reader of repository files and of retired documents. It carries bytes and decides nothing about them: every source read through it for this record is bound by the hash of the bytes it returned, so a reader that returned other bytes moves the record. It changes whenever another record is retired, and what it imports to reach Eve (the content client and the task board library) is not walked.
tools/eve-everywhere/retired-input-pins.mjs yes The table of approved pins, which the reader and the shared verifier look a record up in. It holds the pin of this record once independent review approves it: a record that bound it would be invalidated by its own approval. A pin is review metadata, held outside what is hashed, and each pin names the record, revision and digest it approves.