Evidence for 182.C.19.02, which names eight: face shape, complexion, age
presentation, hair, distinctive features, body proportions, wardrobe, and
permitted changes.
Method#
The committed frame
../2026-09-10-openrouter-face-detection/two-foreground-subjects-plus-bystanders.png
(1408×768, two foreground subjects and four bystanders), analysed with the
models already staged in ~/.cache/oshun-human-video: YuNet for detection,
face_landmarker.task for geometry, selfie_multiclass_256x256.tflite for the
hair / face-skin / clothes segments, and pose_landmarker_lite.task for body
proportions.
Then the same frame through five real lighting variants — two white-balance shifts (per-channel gain, which is what a colour temperature does to a camera) and two one-stop exposure changes — plus a ten-point sweep of smaller changes.
The finding: complexion is dominated by lighting#
| Variant | median lum | red gain | subject 0 L* / ITA | subject 1 L* / ITA |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| reference | 51.8 | 1.028 | 45.5 / −11.6 | 70.6 / +52.1 |
| warm ≈3200 K | 53.7 | 1.195 | 49.0 / −1.6 | 74.1 / +34.6 |
| cool ≈7500 K | 50.6 | 0.887 | 43.1 / −27.8 | 68.6 / +86.9 |
| exposure +1 stop | 94.9 | 1.017 | 82.7 / +46.6 | not measurable |
| exposure −1 stop | 25.9 | 1.028 | 22.4 / −66.5 | 36.9 / −55.6 |
The two subjects differ by 63.7° of Individual Typology Angle in the reference frame — two visibly different people.
A one-stop exposure change moves subject 0 by 58.2°. Almost the entire between-person gap, from nothing but the light. A modest white-balance shift moves it 10.0°.
So a complexion comparison between two frames lit differently is a lighting comparison wearing a complexion's name.
How close does the lighting have to be#
From the sweep:
| change | param | Δ luminance | Δ red gain | subject 0 ΔITA | subject 1 ΔITA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| exposure | −0.50 | −14.90 | 0.000 | −36.5 | −47.5 |
| exposure | −0.25 | −8.24 | 0.000 | −20.6 | −16.6 |
| exposure | −0.10 | −3.53 | 0.000 | −8.4 | −5.5 |
| exposure | +0.10 | +3.14 | +0.001 | +7.2 | n/a |
| white balance | 0.97 | −0.39 | −0.031 | −2.2 | +4.6 |
| white balance | 1.06 | +0.78 | +0.057 | +4.3 | −9.2 |
Slope: about 2.4° of ITA per unit of median luminance, and 90–175° per unit of grey-world red gain (the steeper subject sets the bound). Holding lighting-induced drift near 5° means matching luminance within 2 and red gain within 0.03 — and inside those bounds up to ~5° of any observed drift is still the light, so a complexion finding has to clear it.
Face shape survives lighting#
| Variant | width/height | jaw/width | interocular/width |
|---|---|---|---|
| reference | 0.78023 | 0.78055 | 0.66906 |
| warm ≈3200 K | 0.78736 | 0.77909 | 0.66837 |
| cool ≈7500 K | 0.77791 | 0.77961 | 0.67074 |
| exposure +1 stop | 0.78352 | 0.77957 | 0.66193 |
| exposure −1 stop | 0.79287 | 0.78407 | 0.66374 |
Width-over-height spans 1.92%, jaw width 0.6%, interocular 1.3%. Geometry survives light; colour does not, and that is why the two are gated differently. The shipped constant carries 1.93 — rounded up, because understating a noise floor is the direction that makes a gate fire on the light.
Two more measured facts#
A measurement can disappear. Subject 1's complexion was unavailable at +0.1,
+0.25 and +1.0 stops while present at +0.5. So "not measured in this frame" is
its own outcome and is never folded into "no change" — and the fact that
brightening costs coverage unevenly between subjects belongs to 182.C.19.09.
Small faces yield nothing, correctly. Of six faces detected, only the two
foreground subjects (relative height 0.163 and 0.158) produced geometry or a
complexion. The four bystanders (0.033–0.068) produced neither: the landmarker
declined and the skin segment fell under the pixel floor. That matches the
182.C.17 measurability floor.
Two attributes are not measured at all#
| Attribute | Why |
|---|---|
| age presentation | No age model is staged, and estimating age from face geometry has a documented record of skewing by ethnicity. A number here would be worse than none. |
| distinctive features | Which scar, mole or tattoo matters is a per-subject declaration. Discovering them is a different and more invasive thing than checking a declared one. |
Both go to a person, always, and assertHumanReviewComplete refuses sign-off
while either is outstanding.
Reproducing#
python tools/human-video/evaluator/appearance_attributes.py \
--image docs/domains/isis/human-video/evidence/2026-09-10-openrouter-face-detection/two-foreground-subjects-plus-bystanders.png
Note: analyse one image per process. Stacking MediaPipe task instances in a single interpreter segfaults reproducibly after a handful, which is why the lighting probe forks per image.
Per-item status this evidence supports#
| Item | Was | Is |
|---|---|---|
182.C.19.02 |
not-started |
done; five of seven attributes measured, two routed to human review, colour gated on matched lighting |
182.C.19.08 |
pending | this is a second reason thresholds cannot be universal: the same cutoff means different things per lighting |
182.C.19.09 |
pending | brightening cost coverage unevenly between the two subjects — a fairness slice with a measurement behind it |